|
| |
|
Review commentary by Jeremy Wilson on Lawrence,
the Uncrowned King of Arabia by Michael Asher
(London, Viking, 1998)
previous page | Page
3 | next page |
|
Chapter 1: Apparent Queen Unveiled Her Peerless Light
Early Childhood 1888-96 (13 pages, pp 7-20)
|
| page/para/line |
|
| 12/2/14 |
There
is no evidence whatsoever to support the claim that the Lawrences heard
Canon Christopher preach at Ryde on the Isle of Wight (and for that
reason decided to move to Oxford). The story originated in Knightley and
Simpson's Secret Lives of Lawrence of Arabia (London, Nelson,
1969) and seems to be journalistic speculation. To those who do not know
the area, the Isle of Wight may seem close to Southampton, but at that
date Ryde would have been a considerable journey from the Lawrence home
near Hythe. |
| 13/1/7 |
The
youth organisation which Lawrence helped was not called the Boys
Brigade, but the St. Aldate's Company of the Church Lads Brigade. |
| 13/2/17et
seq. |
Thus
far, Asher's thesis about Lawrence's childhood has involved building up
the influence of Sarah to the utmost possible degree. He complements the
process here by trying to diminish Lawrence's father. He gives no source
for the claim that anyone thought of Thomas Lawrence as "just plain
barmy". The words missing from the quote in line 20 are
"skilled to speak". Apparently this virtue did not fit in with
the impression Asher was trying to create. The source for the anecdote
"he's just Mrs Lawrence's husband" is, again, Celandine
Kennington (remember always, here and elsewhere in these notes, that
Celandine Kennington never met Lawrence's father, but came to know
Lawrence's mother well in her later years). The word "tamed"
put in quotes in line 21 is emphasis by Asher, not a word used by
Lawrence under reference 11 (as the use of quotation marks might be
taken to imply). Incidentally, the word "and" is omitted from
the quote line 22 without ellipsis ("a sportsman and a hard-rider
and drinker"). |
| 14/1/1 |
Lawrence's
father had yachts. Presumably, Asher thinks Lawrence's punting and
canoeing justifies the remark that he became, like his father, a
"devoted . . . waterman". The connection is probably not that
strong. Lawrence wrote long afterwards to an acquaintance "I will
never be a sailor, I'm afraid: born too late, though my father had
yachts and used to take me with him from my fourth year" (DG
Letter No 442). Lawrence disliked journeys on passenger ships; perhaps
he suffered from seasickness. In 1929, as part of his service duties, he
began working as a crewman in RAF seaplane tenders and became part-owner
(by gift) of a small speed-boat. He went on to help develop fast motor
launches for the RAF. However, the appeal seems to have been speed and
mechanics rather than water. It is noticeable that, while his letters
and books contain graphic descriptions of landscapes, he very rarely
commented on the beauty of the sea. |
| 14/1/5-6 |
"But
[Thomas Lawrence's] influence was far less profound than Sarah's".
This is an extraordinary statement, since Lawrence's taste for history,
architecture and archaeology, like his enthusiasm for cycling and
photography, were all probably influenced by his father. Lawrence also
displayed other traits, notably an aristocratic disdain for money, which
almost certainly came from Thomas Chapman. Here again, Asher clearly
wishes to represent the parents as unequal partners - whereas neither
Lawrence himself nor A. W. Lawrence did so. To say they were very
different does not necessarily mean that they were unequal, in terms of
influence over their children rather than housekeeping matters. Next
page |
|
